Costco vs. Amazon

Earlier this month, Ron Lieber wrote an article in the New York Times comparing shopping at Costco to shopping on Amazon.  As the online seller continues to expand its product offerings, you can now purchase many of the staples you would normally purchase at Costco or other warehouse stores with the click of your mouse.  With Amazon’s Subscribe & Save service you can set up a regular recurring list of products that will automatically be delivered to your front door.  So you never have to worry about running out of toilet paper and paper towels and you don’t have to wait in long lines to pay or have an SUV parked outside to haul all of these bulky items home.

Mr. Lieber put together his standard list of staples and purchased one batch from Amazon and compared that to what he would have payed at Costco.  Overall, Amazon was 17 percent more expensive. But, Mr. Lieber reasoned that the time he saved buying online was worth the extra cost. Costco trips are not quick.  One of the only downsides for Amazon,  Mr. Lieber concluded, was the environmental waste that came with the shipping and all of the packaging.

So I started to think about this for myself and wondered whether I would give up my Costco experience to save time.  I don’t think so.  For me, Costco is an experience I love having.  I love going to Costco and seeing the seasonal items, buying their rotisserie chicken, getting my eye glasses and contacts, and buying gift items.  I’ve purchased so many high quality items like furniture that I would never have known about without making a trip to Costco.  So, I don’t think I’ll be giving up my Costco membership anytime soon.  What about you – Costco or Amazon?

3 thoughts on “Costco vs. Amazon

  1. Amazon is great and I shop there often… but there are some things that I really still want to have a “hands-on” experience with before I whip out my credit card. Especially the bigger things that have different features to compare, etc. A book is a book is a book… and it doesn’t make a bit of difference where I buy it. (Although I do have to say that if Costco has the book I’m looking for, it’s probably the same price – and no shipping charge) compared to Amazon. But when I’m looking for computer stuff, I’ve got to see it and check it out before buying… definitely going to Costco for that!

    Bill S.

  2. I use both – Amazon Prime and Costco. I agree Costco all the way for me. I love the experience. I live across the stree and I am there at least once a week. They have the best deals on diapers and we fill up our gas there as well. I save big time on glases and contacts. My son is a sample junkie like his Mom:)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>